(If you'd like to skip this article and see our top pick for a memorabilia retailer, click here.) We’re a nationwide group of memorabilia enthusiasts who created this Website to protect and inform consumers. It's estimated that over half of all memorabilia on the market is fake. With this in mind, our goal is to ensure people buy items that are both authentic and well-priced.
SportsMemorabilia.com Review |
Overview
SportsMemorabilia.com is our top-rated retailer of sports memorabilia across the four dimensions of authenticity, price, ease of shopping and service.
SportsMemorabilia.com has been operational since 1996 and works exclusively with well-known memorabilia suppliers. SportsMemorabilia.com ranks #1 in organic search results on Google, which is a strong indication of both the site’s age and industry credibility. SportsMemorabilia.com deals with memorabilia suppliers who are also in good standing with Google and the Better Business Bureau, which seems to support their promises of authenticity. For more information on the company's authenticity guarantee, you may want to visit the SportsMemorabilia.com Website.
SportsMemorabilia.com appeared to have the most complete authentication process we’ve found. Every item sold through the site comes with a certificate of authenticity issued by the supplier. The company’s suppliers keep records of the merchandise sold through SportsMemorabilia.com, so buyers can retrace their purchases through the supplier to double-check a product’s authenticity. We did not find a competing website that took this many steps to ensure the authenticity of each product sold.
All the merchandise sold over SportsMemorabilia.com was offered at a competitive price. SportsMemorabilia.com’s prices reflect the market value of each product. Through our research, we found that SportsMemorabilia.com's prices were lower than some competitors, but nonetheless kept prices within the median range for a given item.
Buyer protection also seemed to be of particular importance on this website. All online transactions were triple-protected by HackerSafe, THAWTE and 128-bit encryption—the highest level of customer protection available for Internet communication. Buyers who prefer to make their purchases through a customer service representative should be equally satisfied. Through our research, we found the customer service staff at SportsMemorabilia.com to be courteous, professional and well-informed as to the products inquired about.
In addition to a complete, online product selection, SportsMemorabilia.com also offered buyers a number of resources not geared toward a sale. We found a SportsMemorabilia.com blog updated by members of the staff, as well as a Resource Library with articles written about memorabilia fraud and news about teams and players, among other topics. So, their official site is a good place to check out information on sports memorabilia.
The Good
- Selling autographed items online since 1996
- All items undergo unique, multi-dimensional authentication process
- Ranked #1 in Google organic search for "sports memorabilia"
- Friendly and knowledgeable staff
- Competitive pricing
- Comprehensive best-price and authenticity guarantees
The Bad
- Selection is large, so sometimes difficult to select between many different items
- Minimal assortment of items for fringe sports such as wrestling, rugby and cricket
- Large content library focused almost exclusively on baseball, basketball, football and hockey
- Blog updated only a few times per week
The Bottom Line
SportsMemorabilia.com appeared to have the most complete authentication process and authenticity guarantee available. Through our research we found that SportsMemorabilia.com had the most comprehensive selection of products available and easiest, safest checkout procedure. Independent searches through Google and the BBB yielded no negative results and seemed to backup the company’s own promises of product authenticity and good business practices. For the best authenticity, price and service, SportsMemorabilia.com is our top pick.